Monday, April 9, 2018

transitivity - Please help me understand more about intransitive verb and transitive verb


I will give a sentence as an example:



本が深く教えてなかった。



The first question: Could things like book or door or etc... become subject of a transitive verb ?


The second question: Could a transitive verb work without an object ?



Answer



本が深く教えてなかった sounds unnatural and hardly makes sense to me. In casual conversations, we usually say, for example, 本を読んでもよく分からなかった instead, with "I" as the implicit subject.



Your first question is covered in this question: In Japanese, can we say an object asks a question?


As for your second question, yes it's sometimes possible to omit an object. For example, you don't have to repeat the same object again in a conversation like this:



A: その本を読みましたか。 Did you read the book?
B: いいえ、まだです。 No, not yet.
A: では、読んでください。 Then please read it.



However many transitive verbs would make little sense if they completely lack the object. You don't usually say "I say" without specifying what you say. It's better to use an intransitive verb which have a similar meaning (e.g., there is a word "to chat" which does not require an object)


No comments:

Post a Comment

digital communications - Understanding the Matched Filter

I have a question about matched filtering. Does the matched filter maximise the SNR at the moment of decision only? As far as I understand, ...