Saturday, October 5, 2019

minhag - Leaving Sefarim Open and forgetfulness



I heard that there is an idea of not leaving a Sefer open because it can cause forgetfulness.


Is this idea written about anywhere in Halachic literature? If so where is it located?



Answer



This exact question was posed to R. Joseph Messas in Otzar Hamichtavim Vol. II # 954.



שאלת ידידי במכתבך להודיעך אם אמת הדבר אשר שמעת שהמניח ספר פתוח ויוצא בא לידי שכחה ואם דבר זה הוא אפי' בספרי דפוס או רק בס"ת תשובה דבר זה הוא מפורש בהבאה"ט ביו"ד סי' רע"ז וזה"ל וכתב הש"ך וידוע לחכמי האמת דיש מלאך אחד נקרא ש"ד והוא שומר דפין על מי שמניח ספר פתוח ויוצא שמשכח תלמודו ולאו דוקא ס"ת אלא הה"ד שאר ספרים ע"ש וזה דבר סגוליי בלי טעם ושלום


You asked, my friend, in your letter, to inform you whether that which you heard – that if one leaves an open sefer and departs he will come to forget – is true, and if it applies even to printed sefarim or only to a Sefer Torah. Answer: This idea is explicit in the Ba'er Heitev in Yoreh Deiah siman 277, and these are his words. "And the Shach wrote that it is known to the Sages of Truth that there is an angel called S"D and he watches the pages over one who leaves an open sefer and departs, that he should forget his learning. And this is not limited to a Sefer Torah; the same is true for other sefarim". See there. And this is a mystical idea; it has no reason. Peace.



No comments:

Post a Comment

digital communications - Understanding the Matched Filter

I have a question about matched filtering. Does the matched filter maximise the SNR at the moment of decision only? As far as I understand, ...