Wednesday, August 14, 2019

grammar - Is there a difference between んがため and ために?


My JLPT textbook has a section about the use of んがため, which they define as "making an effort in order to realize the intended purpose."


Which to me sounds like plain ol' ために.


For example, they have this example sentence:




祖父{そふ}は100歳{さい}まで生{い}きんがために、食生活{しょくせいかつ}にはとても気{き}をつける。



Isn't that the same as saying:



祖父{そふ}は100歳{さい}まで生{い}きるために、食生活{しょくせいかつ}にはとても気{き}をつける。



...?



Answer



Matt pretty much gave the answer, but I'm going to be cheeky and write a real answer, since I think the question deserves it.


This ん is not the negative, but a contraction of the archaic auxiliary verb む, which expresses intention, prediction etc. As the Goo article says, since the Heian period, it also appeared as ん, and since the Kamakura period as (よ)う. The latter is basically the modern Japanese volitional verb suffix.



I cannot think of any situation where the む form survives in modern Japanese. The ん form survives in certain fossilized constructs:



生きんがため in order to live
言わんとする intend to say



Incidentally, these could also be expressed with the (よ)う form:



生きようがため in order to live
言おうとする intend to say




Edit:


In terms of meaning, there is not much of a difference, but the んがため・んとする versions sound a bit more old-fashioned/solemn. So the difference in use is mostly stylistic.


No comments:

Post a Comment

digital communications - Understanding the Matched Filter

I have a question about matched filtering. Does the matched filter maximise the SNR at the moment of decision only? As far as I understand, ...