I found various formulae of manganese oxohydroxide. Some site says it is $\ce{MnOOH}$, other say it is, $\ce{MnO(OH)2}$. So, which one is correct?
The mineral manganite is considered manganese oxide-hydroxide $\ce{MnOOH}$, but yahoo answer claims that it is $\ce{MnO(OH)2}$.
In Winkler titration, $\ce{MnO(OH)2}$ is formed:
$$\ce{2 MnSO4(s) + O2(aq) → 2 MnO(OH)2(s)}$$
There is some uncertainty about whether the oxidised manganese is tetravalent or trivalent. Some sources claim that $\ce{Mn(OH)3}$ is the brown precipitate, but hydrated $\ce{MnO2}$ may also give the brown colour. So, is $\ce{MnO(OH)2}$ hydrated $\ce{MnO2}$?
So which one is manganese oxohydroxide- $\ce{MnOOH}$ or $\ce{MnO(OH)2}$?
Answer
First, the difference the substances is the oxidation number of manganese. In $\ce{MnOOH}$, the oxidation number of manganese is 3+. While in $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$, the oxidation number for manganese is 4+.
However this doesn't mean $\ce{MnOOH}$ is manganese (III) oxyhydroxide and $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$ is manganese (IV) oxyhydroxide, not for $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$ at least. If you move the element around, you will get $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$ is actually $\ce{H_2MnO_3}$. $\ce{H_2MnO_3}$ is dihydroxy(oxo)manganese which is an acidic substance.
For the question regarding the structure for both substances, I'm sorry that I don't haven't the image but I can describe it (Hope that would do). For $\ce{MnOOH}$, manganese is single bonded with $\ce{OH}$ and manganese is double bonded with oxygen. For $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$, manganese have two single bonds with both of the $\ce{OH}$ and manganese is double bonded with oxygen.
In conclusion, $\ce{MnOOH}$ is manganese (III) oxyhydroxide and $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$ is dihydroxy(oxo)manganese. In structure wise, manganese is single bonded with $\ce{OH}$ and manganese is double bonded with oxygen for $\ce{MnOOH}$. For $\ce{MnO(OH)_2}$, it likes $\ce{MnOOH}$ but have one more single bond with $\ce{OH}$.
No comments:
Post a Comment