One who commits incest is punished with Kares (spiritual separation from the divine source), and any product of incest has the status of a Mamzer.
One who has relations with a Niddah is also punished with Kares, yet the product of such a union does not acquire the status of a Mamzer.
Shouldn't the product of both unions have the same status?
Answer
The Gemara says in Kiddushin that it's derived from a verse "ותהי נדתה עליו" - that even when one is a Nidda, there still is "Haviya" (marriage). Therefore, Kiddushin by a nidda works.
If so, there are no issues of Mamzeirus.
No comments:
Post a Comment