Pyrene doesn't seem to be aromatic. However, sources claim that it is aromatic.
Considerations:
- Pyrene is cyclic. ✓
- Pyrene is flat (planar). ✓
- Pyrene has 16 π electrons.
- Every atom in the ring structure of pyrene is $\ce{sp^2}$ hybridized. ✓
The problem is that pyrene fails the $4n+2$ rule. $4n + 2 \neq 16$ where $n$ is an integer.
Something leads me to suspect that Hückel's rule is an oversimplification here. Or is pyrene indeed non-aromatic?
Answer
Pyrene is aromatic. The Hückel $4n+2$ rule works best with monocyclic ring systems. If you look at the following resonance structure for pyrene with a central double bond, the monocyclic periphery has 14 π electrons (ignoring the greyed-out central double bond), but that is a rationalization.
Nonetheless, pyrene undergoes reactions characteristic of aromatic systems and has ring currents expected from aromatic systems.
No comments:
Post a Comment