I encountered this question which asks how many possible radicals are formed when CHX3CHX2C(CHX3)X3 is monosubstituted by BrX2. The answer given is 3 while I think it should be 4, reasoning that there is a "chiral" carbon if the radical is formed on carbon 3. While arguing with my tutor two questions came to my mind:
- What is the geometry of the CHX3˙CHC(CHX3)X3 radical?
- If the radical is trigonal pyramidal, does it transition quickly between the two possible states? If so are they considered two radicals?
My findings so far:
This answer on SE hints that the exact shape depends on the substituents on the alkyl radical.
Modern Physical Organic Chemistry states that all other (non-methyl) localized radicals are not planar.
Organic Reaction Mechanisms states that the geometry of free radicals is still controversial.
No comments:
Post a Comment