Thursday, November 28, 2019

aqueous solution - Stability of H⁺ ion



I know that HX+ is not possible in water and it is present as HX3OX+. But later on I come to know that even HX3OX+ is not possible and that it is present as HX9OX4X+. Why does this happen? What give that compound so much stability that is not present in HX3OX+ or HX+?



Answer



The formation of bonds nearly always leads to a decrease in energy. This is desirable, since less energy stability, so wherever it is possible, bonds tend to form.


HX+ has an empty s orbital. HX2O: has a lone pair. These easily form something akin to a dative bond (HX2O:HX+), giving HX3OX+. Note that there is no single positively charged hydrogen--the charge is distributed over the entire molecule. Distribution of charge leads to more stability.


Now, HX9OX4X+ (called the "Eigen cation") is even stranger. You can imagine it like this: Three HX2O molecules approach HX3OX+ (remember, this cation is positively charged and water has a lone pair which is attracted to positive charge). Basically, charge-dipole attraction. Of course, the lone pair will "point" towards the hydronium.


Now, these charge-dipole attraction "bonds" resonate. The hydrogens of the central hydronium "detach" from the main molecule and attach to the peripheral ones. In reality, the electron cloud is delocalised and we have partial bonds.


resonance structures of the Eigen cation


Now, the charge is distributed even more. We can have other species like HX7OX3X+, HX15OX7X+, etc. Note that there are crowding issues as well - this is why HX103OX51X+ probably doesn't exist.




Basically, the "original" HX+ is being solvated. The solvation delocalises the charge and forms extra bonds, reducing the net potential energy and increasing stability. That's basically it. It's similar to what happens when you dissolve any ionic compound in water.



No comments:

Post a Comment

digital communications - Understanding the Matched Filter

I have a question about matched filtering. Does the matched filter maximise the SNR at the moment of decision only? As far as I understand, ...